Benincasa Carl a DDS

Dental practices in Sag Harbor don’t always accumulate hundreds of reviews, but Benincasa Carl a DDS has—403 on Google, though no star rating is displayed. That kind of feedback volume suggests a practice that’s been part of the community’s routine for a while. Dentistry in a small coastal village like Sag Harbor tends to be low-key, focused on consistency rather than flash. This office fits that pattern: no frills, just the standard range of general and preventive care you’d expect from a neighborhood dentist.

The address, 286 Hampton St, places it along one of the quieter stretches near the edge of town, where the pace slows just enough to make appointments feel less like a city errand. Hampton Street itself is a mix of older homes and professional offices, the kind of block where you might spot a historic plaque or two if you’re walking by. Dentists here don’t need to compete with the summer tourist rush; they’re more for the year-round crowd, the people who schedule cleanings between seasons or stop in for a quick exam before heading to the marina.

Public feedback is there—403 reviews—but without a visible rating, the details are left to interpretation. Some practices thrive on word-of-mouth in a place like Sag Harbor, where recommendations often come from neighbors or the local hardware store chat. Routine checkups, fillings, and basic restorative work are likely the core of what’s offered, the kind of services that keep a practice steady. No specialty ads, no cosmetic dentistry billboards. Just the fundamentals, handled without fanfare.

For anyone mapping out the location, the directions will confirm it’s a short drive from Main Street, past the whaling museum and the old cinema. Questions about appointments or services? The number to call is (631) 725-1240. No website fluff, no social media push—just a phone line and a street address, the way things still work in some corners of the East End.